JUST WHAT IS the problem with Marshmallow Fluff? It gets zero respect these days. I suppose that brand name doesn’t help. “Fluff” is, after all, the word we use for anything not to be taken seriously. So I’ll begin here by shifting to the generic term for this foodstuff that food snobs scorn: marshmallow creme. There. Does that sound French enough?
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS
Is Marshmallow Fluff acceptable on top of a sundae? Join the conversation below.
People seem to be OK with the marshmallow in its solid form. Maybe it’s the symbiotic relationship it has with the chocolate bar and the Graham cracker, transformed via campfire into the ever-popular s’more.
But I am here to praise the marshmallow in its primordial, formless form. Marshmallow creme has a marvelous capacity to adapt to the shape of our shifting desires. Swirl it into a milkshake for a lush consistency and intense vanilla flavor. Short on time to produce a showstopper dinner-party dessert? Artfully dollop some marshmallow creme atop a scoop of ice cream, blast it with a kitchen torch and call it baked Alaska.
This ingredient is as classic as Ivory soap—and, like that product, possessed of a pristine snowy-white visual appeal and a buoyancy both literal and poetical. Returning for a moment to my brand of choice, Marshmallow Fluff, the retro label is pretty great, too.
Marshmallow creme does have its die-hard devotees. One can attend the What the Fluff? festival each September in Somerville, Mass., and Oct. 8 has been designated National Fluffernutter Day in honor of the sandwich that pairs the sumptuous stuff with peanut butter.
My own passion for marshmallow creme dates from—where else?—childhood. I first encountered the Jersey Mud, a sundae endowed with a billowy marshmallow layer, at the late, great Bon-Air soda fountain in Cedarville, Mich., and you can still order one at the Ice Cream Shoppe on the town’s waterfront. If you can’t get there, the recipe here produces a pretty faithful rendition. Go ahead. Enjoy it.
- Vanilla ice cream
- Chocolate sauce
- Chocolate ice cream
- Marshmallow creme
- Malt powder
- Maraschino cherry
- Fill a sundae glass halfway with vanilla ice cream, lightly packed so the chocolate sauce can snake its way through. Add chocolate sauce. Add chocolate ice cream, lightly packed.
- Add marshmallow creme surrounding chocolate ice cream, leaving just the rounded top of the scoop visible above.
- Sprinkle on malt powder. Place a cherry on top. If you want to be strictly classical, stir the layers into a delicious mud.
To explore and search through all our recipes, check out the new WSJ Recipes page.
Copyright ©2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8
Appeared in the July 17, 2021, print edition as ‘Sweet Nostalgia.’